Release screening results in rounds: leadership, then filmmakers, then everyone else
TL;DR
- Screening results are political. Who sees them first matters almost as much as what they say.
- Send everything to everyone at once and the director hears about the soft third act from an agent before the studio has decided what it thinks.
- Release results in rounds instead: decision owners first, then the filmmakers, then the working teams. Each round gets the version built for it.
- Rounds aren’t about hiding things. They’re about getting the read agreed before it becomes a fight, and making sure nobody learns the most sensitive news secondhand.
- Below: who goes in each round, what each one gets, the alignment call between rounds, a nine-day calendar between screenings, how to handle people outside the rounds, and what to do when it leaks anyway.
The forward you can’t take back
Here’s how it goes wrong. This is illustrative, not a specific movie.
Thursday night, recruited screening. The topline is decent but the third act is soft with one quadrant. The vendor sends the results Friday afternoon. Someone on the studio side forwards the full deck to a list that includes production, marketing, a couple of producers and, through a producer’s office, an agent’s assistant.
By Saturday morning the director has heard, from their agent, that “the third act tested badly.” Not the scores. Not the sample size. Not that the temp score was unfinished. Just the verdict, secondhand.
Monday’s call with the director starts defensive and stays that way. The studio hasn’t even agreed internally on what the results mean, and now it’s negotiating with a filmmaker who heard the worst version first.
Nothing in the research was wrong. The order was.
Why screening results are political
Test screenings aren’t an occasional thing. Kevin Goetz of Screen Engine/ASI told the BBC that around 90% of widely released studio films go through test screenings, and the average movie gets tested about three times. That’s three rounds of results per film, each one landing in the middle of an active negotiation between the studio, the filmmakers and everyone with a stake in the cut.
The stakes are high and personal:
- Final cut. Who has the last word on the movie is often contractual and contested. Screening results are evidence in that negotiation.
- Reputations. Scores reflect on the director, the producers, the cast and the executives who greenlit the project.
- Money. Results shape reshoots, dating, spend and campaign positioning.
- Leaks. Scores show up in the trades.
This year gave a very public example. The Hollywood Reporter reported that Supergirl’s test scores, counted out of 100, never got out of the 60s according to multiple insiders, and that DC Studios forced a bakeoff between a cut from director Craig Gillespie and one from the studio. The studio’s cut reportedly won by just two points. Other insiders disputed how tense things were. Either way, the results and the competing cuts ended up in the press.
That’s the environment screening results land in. Treating them like a normal research deliverable, one deck to one list, ignores all of it.
What rounds are, and what they aren’t
A staged release means the same results go out in a deliberate order, to defined groups, with each group getting a version built for its role.
Rounds are not:
- Hiding results from the filmmakers. They get them, in a form they can use.
- Spinning the data. Every round sees the same findings. What changes is the framing and the level of detail.
- Slowing things down. Done right, the whole sequence fits inside two or three days.
Rounds are:
- Making sure the people who own the decision see the results first and agree on the read.
- Making sure the filmmakers hear it from the studio, framed for the work, not from a forward.
- Making sure the working teams get what affects their plans without getting the full exec debate.
Round 0: the lobby
Before round 1 there’s the night itself. The screening ends, the focus group wraps and someone has the topline on a laptop.
This is where most leaks start, because it’s informal. Someone texts a number to someone else, who texts it on.
Decide before the screening:
- Who gets the topline that night. Usually two or three people: the head of production, the head of marketing and the research lead.
- What the text says. Not just the score. The cut, the sample, the one limit that matters, and “full report to follow.” (There’s a lobby text template in the screening report post.)
- Who sends it. One person. Not five.
Everyone else waits for round 1. Including people who were in the room.
Round 1: decision owners
Who: the executives who own the decisions this screening feeds. Typically production and marketing leadership, plus whoever runs distribution if dating is live. Keep it small. Five or six people, not fifteen.
What they get: the full results.
- Cover line: cut, conditions, sample, skew, decision it feeds
- Top two box and definite recommend, against a stated norm, with the gap
- Quadrant splits with sample sizes
- Scene and character response, confusion points
- Verbatims, grouped by theme
- Findings, interpretations and recommendations, labeled separately
- Limits next to the numbers they limit
- Comparison with the previous screening, if there was one, with what changed in the cut and the room
Format: one-page summary on top, full report behind it. Sent as a link to named people, not an attachment to a list.
Timing: within 24 hours of the screening. Faster if the next screening is soon.
The job of round 1: agree on the read. Not decide everything. Just get to a shared view of what the audience said, what it probably means and what the studio wants to try next.
Between rounds: the alignment call
This is the step most studios skip, and it’s the one that makes rounds work.
After round 1 has the results, hold a 30-minute call with the decision owners and the research lead. Four questions:
- What do we agree the audience said? Findings, not opinions.
- What do we think it means? Interpretation, with disagreements noted.
- What do we want the filmmakers to try? Framed as things to test, not orders.
- What goes to the filmmakers, and how? Which findings, which verbatims, who delivers it.
The output is short. Three to five agreed findings, the framing for the filmmaker conversation and a name for who has that conversation.
Without this call, round 2 turns into each executive giving the director their own version of the results. With it, the filmmakers get one clear message.
Round 2: the filmmakers
Who: the director, the editor and the producers working on the cut. Agree the list in advance.
What they get: a version built for the work.
- The agreed findings, in plain language
- Scene-by-scene response: what landed, what dipped, where people got confused
- Verbatims, grouped by theme, including the good ones
- The things the studio wants to try, framed as experiments for the next cut
- The limits that matter for interpretation: unfinished VFX, temp score, small quadrants
What they don’t get: the internal exec commentary, the debate about whether to recut, budget implications or the marketing team’s concerns about the trailer. Those belong in round 1.
Format: view-only, on its own link. Not a forward of the round 1 deck. That’s the most common way exec commentary ends up in a filmmaker’s inbox.
Tone: notes, not verdicts. Screening results tell you what one audience felt about one cut. They don’t tell you what the movie should be.
There’s a good reminder of that from this year. Tom Holland said that one cut of Spider-Man: Brand New Day took all the notes from test audiences, and that it “totally didn’t work.” The studios didn’t move forward with that version. Test screenings are signal, not instructions. Framing them that way for the filmmakers is better research and better relationships.
Who delivers it: someone with a relationship with the director, usually the production executive on the film, with the research lead available for questions. Not an email from someone the director has never met.
Round 3: the working teams
Who: marketing, distribution, publicity and anyone else whose plans depend on how the movie is playing.
What they get: the parts that affect their work.
- Marketing: who the movie is playing to, the quadrant splits, the gap between rating and recommend, the phrases audiences used unprompted. Those phrases are trailer material.
- Distribution: the overall read, the audience it’s working for and whether anything changes the dating conversation.
- Publicity: what’s working, what audiences are excited about and what to stay away from until the cut changes.
What they don’t get: the filmmaker conversation, the cut debate or the full scene-by-scene. They need the read, not the negotiation.
Format: a short summary for each team, with the full report available on request. Named recipients. Links, not attachments.
Timing: after round 2, usually within a day. The working teams shouldn’t know things the director doesn’t.
What the filmmaker conversation sounds like
The words matter. Here’s a rough shape for the round 2 call. Adjust for the relationship.
Open with what’s working. “The audience was with it for most of the movie. The opening and the second act scored well across the board, and people kept mentioning [character] by name.”
Then the main finding, with context. “Where it dipped was the third act, mainly with women under 25. That’s a smaller group in the sample, so we’re treating it as a signal, not a verdict. The verbatims suggest they didn’t understand why she goes back.”
Then what the audience actually said. Read two or three verbatims. Let the audience do the talking, not the studio.
Then the ask, framed as an experiment. “We’d love to try a version with a setup beat in act two and see if it moves for that group next screening. What do you think?”
Then the limits. “Worth saying the temp score in the last reel probably didn’t help. We’d expect some of that to move once the real music is in.”
Then listen. The director has watched that cut more times than anyone. They may have a better fix than the studio’s.
What to avoid: leading with the score, comparing to other movies the director didn’t make, reading the exec debate back to them and treating every audience comment as a required change.
Rounds for TV and streaming
Series and streaming originals test too, and rounds apply, with a few differences.
- Showrunners replace directors as the central filmmaker in round 2, and writers often need a version focused on story and character.
- Platform executives may sit in round 1 alongside the studio, depending on the deal. Agree in advance who sees what.
- Episodes test separately. Keep each episode’s results tied to its cut and report version, so feedback on the pilot doesn’t get read as feedback on episode four.
- The timeline is often longer between tests, which makes the record of who saw what even more important. People forget what they were told six weeks ago.
Vendors: help your client run rounds
If you run screenings for studios, you can make rounds easier.
- Deliver round-ready. A summary page for round 1, and a separately formatted filmmaker version with scene response and verbatims, without your internal commentary.
- Agree the lobby list with your client before the screening, and stick to it.
- Send links to named people, not attachments to whoever was on the last email.
Studios notice the vendors whose results never leak and never land in the wrong inbox.
People outside the rounds
Most of the damage happens here. There’s a ring of people around every film who aren’t in any round but often end up with the results: agents, managers, talent reps, producers’ assistants, assistants’ assistants, vendors, agencies, people who were in the screening room.
Rules for each:
- Agents and talent reps. Not in any round. If the studio decides they should see something, it’s a separate, limited version, agreed in the alignment call, with its own access record.
- Producers’ offices. Producers in round 2 get round 2. Their assistants don’t get a forward. If an assistant needs access, add them by name.
- Trailer houses and agencies. Round 3 material only, relevant to their brief, on a link that expires when the campaign phase ends.
- The research vendor. They wrote the report. They don’t need the studio’s internal commentary on it.
- People who were in the room. Being at the screening doesn’t put you in round 1.
If you can’t say who’s outside the rounds, you can’t control what reaches them. (More on that in Your tracking deck has no lock on it.)
The gate between rounds
Here’s what makes rounds more than a polite idea: check whether round 1 has actually opened the results before round 2 goes out.
If the head of production hasn’t looked at the screening before the filmmaker conversation, that conversation is going to go badly. Either they’ll be caught off guard by something the director raises, or they’ll be repeating someone else’s read.
So before moving to round 2:
- Check who in round 1 has opened the results.
- If a key decision owner hasn’t, send a one-line nudge pointing to page one.
- Don’t schedule the alignment call until the people who need to be on it have seen the results.
This matters most when the clock is tight. With an average of three screenings per film, the next one is often only a couple of weeks away, sometimes less. A day lost waiting for round 1 is a day the editors don’t have.
A nine-day calendar between screenings
Here’s what a tight turn looks like with the next screening in nine days. Adjust for your schedule.
| Day | What happens |
|---|---|
| Day 0, night | Screening. Topline to the lobby list only. |
| Day 1 | Full results to round 1 as a link. Check opens by end of day. |
| Day 2, morning | Alignment call. Agree findings, framing and who talks to the filmmakers. |
| Day 2, afternoon | Round 2: filmmaker conversation, then their view-only version. |
| Day 3 | Round 3: summaries to marketing, distribution, publicity. |
| Days 3 to 7 | Editorial changes for the next cut. Research lead available for questions. |
| Day 7 | Research and production agree what the next screening needs to test. |
| Day 8 | Recruit and screening logistics locked. |
| Day 9 | Next screening. |
The point of the calendar: the filmmakers have as many days as possible with the agreed read, not with a rumor.
Versions and corrections
Results change. A vendor corrects a quadrant split. A second focus group adds context. The studio decides it read something wrong.
Rules:
- Every round’s version has a report version number, separate from the cut ID.
- Corrections go to everyone who got the original, in every round, with what changed.
- Old versions are retired. If your delivery method lets you replace or switch off the old link, do it. Otherwise people keep quoting the wrong number.
- Record who saw which version. When someone says “the third act tested at 55,” you want to know which version they read.
When it leaks anyway
It will, sometimes. Supergirl’s scores ended up in the trades. Plenty of others have too.
Have a plan before it happens:
- Find the route. Who had access to the version that leaked? A record of who received and opened each round makes this a short list instead of a guess.
- Talk to the filmmakers first. If results leak, the director should hear from the studio before they read it online.
- Correct the record internally. The leaked version is usually the worst one: the verdict without the context. Make sure everyone inside has the full picture.
- Tighten the gap that leaked. Usually it’s a forward from round 1 or a producer’s office. Fix that specific route next time.
The rounds plan
Fill this in before the screening, not after.
| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who (named) | [names] | [names] | [names] |
| What they get | Full results + summary | Agreed findings, scenes, verbatims, things to try | Team-specific summaries |
| What they don’t get | n/a | Exec commentary, budget, marketing debate | Filmmaker conversation, cut debate |
| Format | Link, named, summary on top | View-only link, separate | Link per team |
| Delivered by | Research lead | Production exec, research lead on call | Research lead |
| Timing | Within 24 hours | After alignment call | Within a day of round 2 |
| Gate | n/a | Round 1 has opened | Round 2 delivered |
Plus a line for who’s outside the rounds, and what, if anything, they get.
Mistakes that turn results into fights
One deck, one list. Everyone sees everything at once, including the people who shouldn’t see it first.
Skipping the alignment call. Each exec gives the director their own version.
Forwarding the round 1 deck to the filmmakers. The exec commentary goes with it.
Delivering verdicts, not notes. “The third act doesn’t work” starts a fight. “One quadrant rated the third act lower, here’s what they said, here’s what we’d like to try” starts a conversation.
Treating audience notes as instructions. The cut that takes every note literally is rarely the best cut.
Letting the lobby text go wide. The number without the context travels furthest.
Not checking round 1 opened it. The filmmaker conversation happens with an exec who hasn’t read the results.
Not knowing who had access. When it leaks, nobody can say how.
Before you send round 1
- The rounds plan is filled in with names
- The lobby list and lobby text are agreed
- Round 1 version has the cover line, the gap and limits on page one
- Sent as a link to named people
- Alignment call is booked
- Round 2 version is built separately, view-only, without exec commentary
- The filmmaker conversation has an owner
- Round 3 summaries are drafted per team
- Rules for people outside the rounds are agreed
- You’ll know who opened each round before the next one goes out
Why rounds help the research team too
Rounds protect the filmmakers and the studio. They also protect research.
When results go to everyone at once, the research team ends up defending its numbers in a dozen separate conversations, each with someone who read a different part of the deck. When results go out in rounds, research presents once to round 1, helps shape one message for the filmmakers and hands clean summaries to the working teams.
That’s less time arguing about whether the screening was right, and more time on what the next one should test.
The point
Screening results are some of the most consequential and sensitive research a studio produces. They shape the cut, the campaign, the date and the relationship with the filmmakers. And they arrive in the middle of a negotiation that’s already tense.
The research can be excellent and still do damage if it arrives in the wrong order. A director who hears a verdict from an agent, an exec who walks into a filmmaker call without having read the results, a publicist quoting a number nobody agreed on: none of that is a research problem. It’s a sequencing problem.
Decide the order before the lights go down. Give each round what it needs. Check round 1 has read it before round 2 goes out. Know who has what.
Same results. Better order. Fewer fights.
Presitt releases screening results in rounds: a separate, view-only version for each group, and a record of who opened each round before the next one goes out.
Want the full delivery process? Email me at joey.stawiarski@sharpr.com for The Studio Research Handoff Playbook.
Questions people ask
Who should see test screening results first?
The executives who own the decisions the screening feeds, usually production and marketing leadership, plus distribution if dating is live. Keep it to five or six people. They get the full results within 24 hours and hold a short alignment call to agree on the read before anything goes to the filmmakers.
When should the director see test screening results?
After the decision owners have agreed on the read, usually the day after round 1. The director should hear it from the studio, in a conversation with someone they have a relationship with, before they hear it from an agent or read it in the trades. They get a separate, view-only version without the internal exec commentary.
What should filmmakers get from a test screening?
The agreed findings in plain language, scene-by-scene response, verbatims grouped by theme including the positive ones, the things the studio wants to try framed as experiments for the next cut, and the limits that matter for interpretation, like unfinished VFX, temp score and small quadrants. They shouldn't get exec commentary, budget implications or marketing debate.
What is the alignment call after a test screening?
A 30-minute call with the decision owners and the research lead, held after round 1 has seen the results. It answers four questions: what the audience said, what it probably means, what the studio wants the filmmakers to try and who delivers that message. The output is three to five agreed findings and one owner for the filmmaker conversation.
What should a studio do when test screening results leak?
Use the record of who received and opened each round to find the route. Talk to the filmmakers before they read it online. Make sure everyone inside has the full picture, not just the leaked verdict. Then close the specific gap, which is usually a forward from round 1 or a producer's office.