Your newsletter is a graveyard of links nobody opened

October 30, 2026 · Presitt Open ratesApple MailClicksConsultants

I used to send a research roundup every Friday. Eleven links, a cute intro, a “what I’m reading” section I was weirdly proud of. Took me three hours. I’d hit send around 4:30, close the laptop, and go get a beer feeling like a thought leader.

Then I built software that tracked what people actually did with research after it got sent to them. And I pointed it at my own newsletter.

Reader, I was not a thought leader. I was a guy throwing PDFs off a bridge.

Most of my links got zero clicks. Not low. Zero. One link I’d spent 40 minutes reading and summarizing was opened by exactly one person, and that person was me, testing the email.

If you curate and send stuff for a living - solo researcher, consultant, analyst with a list - this is probably happening to you too. You just can’t see it. So let’s look.

Your open rate is a liar

First, the bad news. The number you check every Monday is mostly made up.

Apple Mail Privacy Protection pre-loads emails on its own servers, which registers as an “open” whether a human looked or not. So a big chunk of your opens are a robot in Cupertino glancing at your subject line and moving on with its day.

And even a real open means nothing. I open 60 newsletters a week. “Open” means my thumb touched it on the way to archive. I am a statistic in your dashboard and a ghost in your life.

Clicks are better. Clicks mean a human did a thing. But a click still doesn’t tell you if they read it, bailed in four seconds, or got stuck on a cookie banner and gave up on capitalism.

So you’re running a business on a number that’s half fiction and doesn’t measure the thing you care about. Cool. Very normal. Everyone does it.

The thing you’re actually selling

Nobody subscribes to your newsletter for the links. They can find links. Google exists. LinkedIn exists, unfortunately.

They subscribe because you picked. You read the 80-page report so they didn’t have to. You found the one chart that matters. Your curation is the product.

And you have zero feedback on the curation. None. You know if the subject line worked. You don’t know if the picks were any good.

That’s like a chef who only finds out whether people walked into the restaurant. Never whether they ate. That chef is still serving the deconstructed beet thing from 2019 and telling his friends it’s “doing great.”

I’ve looked at a stupid amount of this data, mostly from big research teams at big companies, and the causes of death are pretty consistent. In rough order of body count:

Position. Link one gets the clicks. Link two gets fewer. By link seven you’re writing to nobody. People read newsletters like a diner menu, top down, until they find something or get bored. They get bored fast. If your best item is in slot eight because you “organized by theme,” you hid it. Congrats on the theme.

Too many links. Eleven links isn’t generous, it’s homework. Your reader opened your email to avoid work and you handed them a reading list. Five good links will beat twelve okay ones basically every time. I’ve argued this in enough meetings that people now leave when I start.

Gates. You linked a report behind a form that wants their work email, company size, phone number, and mother’s maiden name. They clicked, saw it, left. In your head that link got read. In reality it bounced off a wall and died in the parking lot.

PDFs on phones. I love a PDF. My entire career is PDFs. But a 48-page PDF on a phone is a hostage situation. Pinch, zoom, lose your place, quit. If the good stuff is on page 31, say so. Better, screenshot the chart and put it right in the email.

Blurbs that summarize instead of sell. “New report on supply chain resilience.” Okay? And? The blurbs that get clicked give a reason. A surprising number, a hot take, a page reference. “The chart on page 12 is going to start a fight in your next ops meeting.” I’m clicking that. I don’t even work in ops.

It just wasn’t that interesting. Sorry. Sometimes you liked it more than they did. This is the one you can’t feel from the inside, and it’s the one you most need data for.

Free stuff you can do today

You don’t need software for most of this. Do these first. If they fix it, great, don’t pay me.

Cut to five links. If you can’t pick five, that tells you something, probably that none of them are that good. Put the most interesting one first, not the most important one. Important is how you lose people.

Rewrite every blurb as a reason to click. Page numbers are cheat codes. “Skip to page 9” turns a 40-page PDF into a 30-second ask.

Ask your readers. Once a quarter, put one line at the bottom: “Reply with the one link this month that was actually useful.” The answers will humble you. Half the time it’s the thing you almost cut.

Prune your list. Anyone who hasn’t clicked in six months isn’t a reader. They’re a hostage. Send a “still want this?” email and drop anyone who doesn’t answer. Your numbers go up, your deliverability goes up, and you stop writing for ghosts.

Stop attaching PDFs. Attachments get flagged, clog inboxes, and once they’re out you’ve lost them forever. Host it and link it.

That gets you a lot of the way. What it doesn’t get you is the answer to “who actually read this, and did they read the good part.”

Fine, the product part

We built Presitt because we spent years building this for giant enterprise research teams, and kept watching solo people try to do the same job with Mailchimp and prayer.

You put together a send. Links, docs, decks, whatever. You send it. Presitt tells you who opened which item, how long they spent on it, and who forwarded it.

That’s the product. $29 a month. No sales call. No demo. No onboarding guy named Brayden who wants to “understand your goals for Q1.” You sign up, you send something, you find out your biggest client read every word and the guy you were trying to impress didn’t open it. Painful, but now you know.

What it’s not: an email marketing platform. No drips, no automations, no A/B testing your subject lines into oblivion. If you’re blasting 80,000 people, go use a real ESP, we won’t be offended. Presitt is for people sending to dozens or a few hundred people who actually matter to their business.

And it’s not magic. If your curation is boring, Presitt will just show you, in high definition, that it’s boring. Some people find that motivating. Some people cancel. Honestly both are reasonable.

Why consultants should care more than anyone

If you’re a consultant, your newsletter isn’t content. It’s pipeline wearing a cardigan. Client briefs are how that pipeline stays visible between projects.

Every person on your list is a past client, a current client, or someone you want to be a client. When one of them reads your entire send three weeks in a row, that’s not a “highly engaged subscriber.” That’s someone thinking about hiring you. You should probably call them.

When a prospect forwards your thing to two people on their team, that’s a buying committee forming and you’re not in the room. You should probably be in the room.

Open rates can’t tell you any of this. You’re sitting on the most useful sales signal you have and reading it as a vanity metric.

The part nobody likes

Most curators don’t track this stuff, and it’s not because tools don’t exist. It’s because they’re a little afraid of what they’ll find.

I get it. You worked hard on this. Finding out your favorite section is the one everyone skips feels personal.

But your readers are already voting. Every week. With their thumbs, scrolling past item eight on their way to lunch. Not looking at the results doesn’t change the results. It just means you keep losing and blame the algorithm.

The curators who get really good, the ones people forward with “you have to subscribe to this,” aren’t better writers than you. They just looked at the numbers, winced, and changed something. Then did it again the next week. It’s not glamorous. It’s mostly wincing.

If you skipped to the bottom (we see you, and so would Presitt)

Your open rate is half fiction. Clicks are better. Knowing who actually read the thing is best.

Cut to five links. Best one first. Blurbs are reasons, not summaries. Page numbers are cheat codes. Prune the ghosts. Stop attaching PDFs.

If you want to see who’s reading what, that’s Presitt. $29 a month. No Brayden.

Now go look at last week’s send and guess which link died first. You already know.

Questions people ask

Why is my newsletter open rate so high if nobody clicks?

Apple Mail Privacy Protection pre-loads emails on Apple's servers, which registers as an open even when no person looked. A real open often means someone tapped the email on the way to archive. Clicks, and time spent on each item, are closer to whether anyone read it.

How many links should a curated newsletter include?

Five. Link one gets the clicks and attention drops fast after that. By link seven you are writing to almost nobody. Five strong links beat twelve okay ones, and the most interesting item should be first.

What should I track instead of newsletter open rate?

Track which items a specific person opened, how long they spent, and whether they forwarded the send. That shows whether your curation worked, not whether a mail scanner loaded the message.

How much does Presitt cost?

Presitt is $29 a month. One seat for the person who sends. No sales call and no demo. It is for lists of dozens or a few hundred people, not blasts to tens of thousands.

← All posts